The Sheffield Rules

The Sheffield Rules were the first major football code produced by a club. Unlike the Cambridge Rules, which came out of a university, the Sheffield code was written by the players of a single town club to govern their own matches. The rules were agreed at the club's annual meeting in 1858 and first printed the following year. It survived as a working set of rules in Sheffield from then until the late 1870s, when it was finally merged with the Laws of the Game agreed by the Football Association.

The rules helped introduce or standardise several features that later became part of the modern game, and the Sheffield football scene of the 1860s and 1870s was one of the most active in England. The code's place in football's history is as the main parallel tradition to the Cambridge and London codes that fed into the FA.

Sheffield Football Club was founded in 1857 by two local sportsmen, William Prest and Nathaniel Creswick, who had been organising informal football among members of the Sheffield Cricket Club and wanted a settled club of their own. The club's first matches were played among its own members. From their first meeting on Boxing Day 1860, matches against Hallam FC became one of football's earliest local rivalries.

At its founding, Sheffield FC pre-dated the FA by six years and used its own version of football. The club is recognised by FIFA as the oldest football club in the world, and has continued as a football club since 1857. Its early matches were among the first organised club football fixtures anywhere.

The Sheffield Rules used throw-ins from the touchline, helped establish free kicks for fouls as the code developed, and developed several restarts after the ball went out of play. The rouge appeared in the Sheffield code before later disappearing; it was a tie-breaking score used to separate sides level on goals, awarded when the ball was forced behind the goal line to one side of the posts. Goals always counted for more, and any goal outweighed any number of rouges. A corner restart was discussed in 1867, and the corner kick was formally adopted by the Sheffield FA in 1868.

The Sheffield code took a stricter view of physical play than some of the public school games. Hacking and tripping were banned, and the ball was mostly kicked rather than carried. In that respect, the Sheffield Rules were close to the Cambridge approach, although they differed on several specific points, including how offside was judged.

As more clubs formed in the Sheffield area through the early 1860s, the need for a regional body grew. The Sheffield Football Association was founded in 1867 to govern football in the area, run a code of rules and organise competitions between local clubs. It was the world's second oldest football association, behind only the FA itself.

The Sheffield football scene also produced one of the earliest football tournaments, the Youdan Cup, played in 1867, and the Cromwell Cup, which followed in 1868. These pre-dated the FA Cup by several years and are among the earliest examples of organised cup football in association football.

From 1866 onwards, Sheffield sides began playing matches against London clubs and FA representative sides. The first of these matches, at Battersea Park in 1866, was played under FA rules, which the Sheffield side found less familiar. These fixtures continued through the late 1860s and early 1870s, with both sides learning from each other's code.

The contact was important. The FA adopted or helped standardise several Sheffield features — including throw-ins from the touchline, corner kicks and the rules around free kicks — across the decade that followed. In turn, Sheffield gradually adapted to FA conventions. By the mid-1870s the two codes had moved much closer together, and a formal merger was within reach.

The merger was a gradual process across the 1870s rather than a single decision. Sheffield FC and the Sheffield FA accepted more and more of the FA's conventions as they played against London clubs, while the FA adopted or helped standardise some of Sheffield's strongest ideas. By 1877, the Sheffield FA had formally adopted the FA's Laws of the Game, ending the parallel code.

Some Sheffield features survived the merger. Throw-ins, corner kicks and free kicks for fouls all stayed in the game and remain part of the modern Laws. Others — including the rouge — did not survive. The Sheffield FA itself continues to govern football in the Sheffield area, although it operates within the broader structure of the English game.